When A Right Is Difficult To Use
Justice is often described as a right, not a privilege reserved for people with money. Yet having a legal right and being able to enforce it are not always the same thing. Imagine two people with similar legal problems. One can afford a lawyer, obtain advice early, gather evidence and attend court without losing the income needed to support a household. The other struggles to pay for transport, legal assistance and repeated court appearances. Both may have valid claims, but their practical ability to pursue them is very different. This does not mean that money determines what a judge will decide. Courts are required to decide cases according to the law and evidence. The concern arises earlier: money can affect whether a person understands their options, obtains professional help, prepares a case and continues with proceedings. The question, therefore, is not simply whether justice is formally available. It is whether ordinary people can realistically reach it.
The Cost Of Legal Representation
Lawyers help people understand their rights, prepare documents, assess evidence and follow court procedures. Professional advice can be especially important in complicated disputes. Legal services, transport, document preparation and time away from work all carry costs. A person with adequate resources may obtain advice promptly, while someone with limited means may delay, rely on informal guidance or appear without a lawyer. Self-representation is not automatically unsuccessful, and a more expensive lawyer does not guarantee a better result. However, unfamiliarity with procedure can make it difficult to present a claim or defense, particularly where technical rules, substantial evidence or strict deadlines are involved. The inequality may not lie in the legal rights available to each person. It may lie in the resources each can bring to the process.
What Does The Nigerian Constitution Provide?
The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended) contains important fair-hearing protections. Section 36(1) provides that, in determining a person’s civil rights and obligations, that person is entitled to a fair hearing within a reasonable time before an independent and impartial court or tribunal. For criminal proceedings, section 36(4) separately guarantees a public fair hearing within a reasonable time. Section 36(6) sets out safeguards for a person charged with a criminal offense. These include being informed promptly, in a language the person understands, of the nature of the charge; receiving adequate time and facilities to prepare a defense; defending oneself personally or through a legal practitioner of one’s choice; examining prosecution witnesses and calling defense witnesses; and receiving an interpreter without payment where necessary. These are significant protections. However, section 36(6)(c) should not be mistaken for an automatic guarantee that the State must pay for a lawyer in every case. It recognizes the right to defend oneself or to use a legal practitioner of one’s choice. The Constitution also addresses financial assistance in section 46(4)(b). It directs the National Assembly to make provision for financial assistance to an indigent Nigerian whose Chapter IV rights have been infringed, or to enable that person to engage a legal practitioner to pursue the claim. The provision is tied to the enforcement of Chapter IV rights and includes safeguards requiring a substantial allegation and a real need for financial or legal aid. It is not a blanket promise of publicly funded representation in every civil or criminal dispute. The distinction matters: constitutional rights establish important protections, but practical arrangements for legal assistance also depend on legislation and implementation.
Poverty And The Criminal Justice Process
Criminal proceedings can have severe consequences. An accused person may need to understand the charge, examine evidence and prepare a defense. Without affordable assistance, effective participation can become harder. The United Nations General Assembly adopted the United Nations Principles and Guidelines on Access to Legal Aid in Criminal Justice Systems through Resolution A/RES/67/187 on 20 December 2012. The guidelines describe legal aid as an essential element of a fair, humane and efficient criminal justice system. They encourage States to ensure access to legal aid for people who are detained, arrested, suspected of or charged with offenses, particularly where imprisonment or the death penalty may be imposed. The resolution provides international guidance; it is not a substitute for Nigeria’s domestic legislation. Its importance is that it recognizes legal assistance as part of a fair criminal process, rather than a luxury available only to those who can pay.
Legal Aid In Nigeria
Nigeria has a statutory legal-aid framework under the Legal Aid Act 2011, which establishes the Legal Aid Council and provides for legal aid, advice and access-to-justice services. Section 8 describes three broad areas of service: criminal defense; advice and assistance in civil matters, including court representation; and community legal services. Assistance is subject to merits and indigence tests. The Act’s Second Schedule identifies criminal offenses for which criminal legal aid may be provided. Specified civil matters include accident and employee-compensation claims, claims involving breaches of Chapter IV fundamental rights, and certain civil claims arising from criminal activities. Eligibility is not unlimited. Section 10 sets an income-based threshold linked to the national minimum wage, while allowing exceptional assistance above that threshold and, in specified circumstances, contributory assistance. Section 11 requires a person’s income and personal and real property to be considered, together with prescribed commitments. The particular facts and statutory criteria therefore matter. Legal aid can provide advice and representation to people who might otherwise be unable to afford them. But the scheme can only close the justice gap if people know about it, can reach its services and can obtain timely help. Funding, staffing, geographical access and public awareness are therefore essential.
What The Research Tells Us
Research offers evidence of how financial circumstances can affect the routes people take to resolve legal problems. HiiL’s 2021 report, Poverty and Access to Justice, analysed survey data from 71,892 people across 13 countries, including Nigeria. Drawing on earlier Nigerian Justice Needs and Satisfaction data, it reported that low-income people in Nigeria were two times less likely to engage courts and more than three times less likely to engage lawyers than high-income people. The report also discusses costs, time, difficulty obtaining professional advice and distrust of formal justice mechanisms as barriers. Those findings should be read carefully. The report describes associations in survey data; it does not prove that wealth buys favorable judgments. HiiL stresses that poverty and access to justice have a complex, non-linear relationship and that outcomes are also shaped by the type and seriousness of the legal problem and the dispute-resolution process used. A separate HiiL study, Justice Needs and Satisfaction in Nigeria 2023, was based on 6,573 randomly selected Nigerian adults. It reported that approximately 81 percent of respondents had experienced at least one legal problem in the previous year. Among people who took action to address their most serious problem, 5 percent reported seeking help from a lawyer and 1 percent from a formal court; family members and friends were much more commonly consulted. These figures describe the study’s respondents, not every Nigerian, and do not establish that cost was the only reason people chose informal help. Taken together, the studies support a measured conclusion: financial resources can influence access to professional and formal justice services, but they are only one part of a wider picture.
What Needs To Change?
Improving access to justice requires practical steps that make legal rights usable. First, legal-aid services need adequate funding, trained personnel and effective coverage across the country. Second, public legal education should help people understand their basic rights, where to seek assistance and what services may be available. Third, lawyers, professional associations and law firms can strengthen pro bono services for people who cannot afford representation. Universities and law faculties can also support properly supervised law clinics and community legal-education programs. These initiatives can provide basic legal information and, within professional rules and appropriate supervision, assistance. Finally, courts and justice institutions should continue to reduce avoidable delays, simplify procedures where possible and make information easier to understand. These measures cannot remove every disadvantage associated with poverty, but they can narrow the gap between having a right and enforcing it.
Conclusion: Justice Must Not Have A Price
Money does not lawfully determine the outcome of a case. A court must decide according to the law and evidence, not the wealth of the parties. Yet financial resources can influence whether a person obtains legal advice, prepares a case, attends proceedings and pursues a remedy. That is the real concern. A legal system may promise equal protection, but that promise is weakened when the practical ability to enforce rights depends heavily on a person’s financial circumstances. Justice must be more than a principle written in a constitution or statute. It must be something people can meaningfully access, regardless of income. Justice should be determined by the law, not by the size of a person’s bank account.
References
Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended). Consolidated version incorporating the First to Fifth Alterations, Policy and Legal Advocacy Centre (PLAC), revised 2023, reprinted 2024.
Legal Aid Act 2011, Act No. 17. Federal Republic of Nigeria Official Gazette No. 66, Vol. 98, 15 June 2011.
United Nations General Assembly. Resolution A/RES/67/187, United Nations Principles and Guidelines on Access to Legal Aid in Criminal Justice Systems, adopted 20 December 2012.
Gramatikov, M., Kaur, R., Banks, I. and Heijstek-Ziemann, K. (2021). Poverty and Access to Justice. Hague Institute for Innovation of Law (HiiL). https://www.hiil.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/HiiL-report-Poverty-and-Access-to-Justice-web.pdf
HiiL (2023). Justice Needs and Satisfaction in Nigeria 2023: Legal Problems in Daily Life. https://www.hiil.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Justice-Needs-and-Satisfaction-in-Nigeria-2023.pdf
Comments
No comments yet.